Difference between revisions of "New monads/MonadRandomSplittable"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m |
|||
Line 45: | Line 45: | ||
== Laws == |
== Laws == |
||
− | It is not clear to me exactly what [[Monad laws|laws]] <hask>splitRandom</hask> should satisfy, besides monadic variations of the "split laws" from the |
+ | It is not clear to me exactly what [[Monad laws|laws]] <hask>splitRandom</hask> should satisfy, besides monadic variations of the "split laws" from the [http://haskell.org/onlinereport/random.html Haskell Library Report] |
For all terminating <hask>ma</hask> and <hask>mb</hask>, it should hold that |
For all terminating <hask>ma</hask> and <hask>mb</hask>, it should hold that |
Revision as of 20:04, 17 November 2006
When using New monads/MonadRandom, one may also want to use a MonadRandom
equivalent of RandomGen
's split
function:
class (MonadRandom m) => MonadRandomSplittable m where
splitRandom :: m a -> m a
instance (Monad m, RandomGen g) => MonadRandomSplittable (RandomT g m) where
splitRandom ma = (RandomT . liftState) split >>= lift . evalRandomT ma
MonadRandomSplittable can then be derived for Rand by GHC:
newtype Rand g a = Rand { unRand :: RandomT g Identity a }
deriving (Functor, Monad, MonadRandom, MonadRandomSplittable)
Example of usage
test :: Rand StdGen [Bool] -> (Int, [Bool], Int)
test ma = evalRand (liftM3 (,,) (getRandomR (0,99)) ma (getRandomR (0,99)))
(mkStdGen 0)
Then
*MonadRandom> test (replicateM 0 getRandom)
(45,[],55)
*MonadRandom> test (replicateM 2 getRandom)
(45,[True,True],0)
*MonadRandom> test (splitRandom $ replicateM 0 getRandom)
(45,[],16)
*MonadRandom> test (splitRandom $ replicateM 2 getRandom)
(45,[False,True],16)
*MonadRandom> case test undefined of (a,_,c) -> (a,c)
*** Exception: Prelude.undefined
*MonadRandom> case test (splitRandom undefined) of (a,_,c) -> (a,c)
(45,16)
Laws
It is not clear to me exactly what laws splitRandom
should satisfy, besides monadic variations of the "split laws" from the Haskell Library Report
For all terminating ma
and mb
, it should hold that
liftM3 (\a _ c -> (a,c)) getRandom ma getRandom === liftM3 (\a _ c -> (a,c)) getRandom mb getRandom
For monad transformers, it would also be nice if
splitRandom undefined === splitRandom (return ()) >> lift undefined
For example,
>runIdentity $ runRandomT (splitRandom (return ()) >> lift undefined >> return ()) (mkStdGen 0)
((),40014 2147483398)
>runIdentity $ runRandomT (splitRandom undefined >> return ()) (mkStdGen 0)
((),40014 2147483398)
But
>runRandomT (splitRandom (return ()) >> lift undefined >> return ()) (mkStdGen 0)
*** Exception: Prelude.undefined
>runRandomT (splitRandom undefined >> return ()) (mkStdGen 0)
*** Exception: Prelude.undefined
I have no idea how to express this idea for monads that aren't transformers though. But for Rand
it means that:
>runRand (splitRandom undefined >> return ()) (mkStdGen 0)
((),40014 2147483398)
Why?
In replicateM 100 (splitRandom expensiveAction)
There are no RNG-dependencies between the different expensiveActions, so they may be computed in parallel.